The client described below is a composite drawn from patterns I’ve seen across my work with
clients navigating cross-cultural identity; details have been substantially altered and no single
person’s history is represented.
I want to share some reflections from my ongoing work with a client whom I’ll call Anaya, a
woman in her forties who grew up in India and has lived in Europe for over a decade. Much
of my practice serves clients of South Asian origin living across several countries, and my
own experience of cultural migration and reinvention shapes both what I notice in the room
and how I understand it. Anaya came to me, looking for a counselor who could meet her from
within a shared cultural world.
Anaya has spent her adult life moving between countries and reinventing herself
professionally and personally each time. She entered a long-term relationship with a partner
from a different cultural background and the two later relocated internationally for family
reasons. This move came with its own losses and required her to rebuild much of her life
again from scratch.
The presenting concern: An existential trigger
Anaya arrived in counselling at a moment I’d describe as an existential crisis of belonging. The
immediate spark was being left out of a family decision regarding a place that had once been
her home for many years. Being excluded from something that mattered deeply to her
crystallized a feeling that had been quietly building for a long time. In her first session, she
seemed to be confronting all four of Yalom’s existential givens at once: freedom (what do I
actually want from this relationship?), isolation (no one in this house truly meets me),
meaning (who am I in this family, and what is it for?), and mortality. She expressed mortality
as a sense that only a limited number of meaningful seasons might remain.
Three unmet needs
Kohut’s self-psychology holds that the self needs three kinds of relational experience to stay
cohesive: to be mirrored, meaning to be seen and affirmed, and to have someone stronger and
calmer to idealize and lean on occasionally. It also needs a sense of twinship: the feeling of
being fundamentally like another person. In Anaya’s case, all three have gone unmet across
her closest relationships.
Within her family, she has long been positioned as the reliable one: the organizer, the carer,
the person who is not supposed to need anything. That role has left her unmirrored: no one
asks how she’s doing, and she has come to feel that she’s allowed to be capable but not
allowed to be human. In one session she put it simply: she doesn’t feel cared for, she feels she
must be perfect, and that the people closest to her want her to mother them rather than see her.
The idealizing need tells a similar story. Early in the relationship, her partner represented
steadiness and strength she could lean into. Over time, that figure became harder to reach and
more avoidant, more withdrawn into his own preoccupations than connected to her. My
working hypothesis is that Anaya has redirected this need inward, essentially idealizing her
own competence and self-sufficiency as a substitute. This strategy keeps her functioning
however deepens her isolation.
The twinship need may be the most painful gap of all, as Anaya has crossed languages and
continents while carrying heavy caregiving and household responsibilities for years. She has
also moved through a major health transition largely alone. Few people around her can fully
grasp what that combination feels like from the inside. Part of what she’s found in our work
together is a partial version of that twinship: someone who understands, at least in part, what
it is to live between worlds. It’s been both a gift to the counselling process and something I
have to stay alert to, so it doesn’t distort the frame.
Recognition, not function
Drawing on the intersubjective tradition, particularly Benjamin’s idea of mutual recognition, I
think what Anaya hungers for most, and what her system most consistently withholds, is
being seen as a full subject rather than related to as a function. She described our first in-
person session as feeling “more alive” than our remote sessions, which said a great deal about
how rare that experience of real contact has been for her.
The humanistic and existential thread
For Anaya, Rogers’s three core conditions have not been reliably present in her primary
relationships: empathy, unconditional positive regard and congruence. As a result, she has
largely had to build her sense of worth through achievement. In our work, her self-rated sense
of clarity roughly doubled over the course of counselling and she described no longer feeling
like she was “drowning.”
Underneath her question, is this the right relationship for the next chapter of my life?, sits a
more existential one: does the life she built still feel true to her, or has she been living inside
expectations that were never fully hers?
Themes that keep surfacing
Several themes keep coming up in our work. Belonging and exclusion show up in family
decisions and living arrangements that leave her on the periphery. Strength has become an
assigned role, trapping her in a position where she is not permitted to need anything. Over
time, she has shifted from asking, “Am I allowed to make changes?” to asking, “Is this still
the right path for me?” This reflects a real movement toward self-authorship. There is also
layered, unmourned grief. This includes the losses of places and the relationship she had once
hoped for, alongside the changes of midlife. Her body often seems to know things before her
mind catches up, through a heavy chest, sudden chills or a falling sensation.
My own reflections
I noticed early on that I was unconsciously matching Anaya’s fast, efficient pace. By the end
of sessions, I often felt swept along, as if I had been carried by a strong current. Recognizing
this helped me understand that staying at her pace would keep us circling her narrative
without reaching what sat underneath it. As I deliberately slowed things down, her emotional
world opened up.
I’m drawn to this work in part because her experience resonates with my own history of living
between cultures. This has made the relationship feel genuinely collaborative, almost like
walking alongside a fellow traveler. That resonance is a real asset in the room, but I also have
to watch that it doesn’t pull my attention toward her strength and progress at the expense of
sitting with her grief and uncertainty.
In a recent session, as she reflected on an upcoming personal milestone, she began to ask
herself whether she wanted to acknowledge it at all. Now she is asking, perhaps for the first
time, what she herself wants. This is not a small step. It may be the beginning of something
new.